Example
ENERGY = ENERGY_STANDARD × CANONIC
= Structure(energy) × (C1, C2, Temporal, Relational, C5, C6)
Lattice: 6 governance checks = ENTERPRISE (#63)
| Dimension | Bit | Energy Governance |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | private | Grid stability declarations — no dispatch without verified compliance |
| C2 | private | Metering evidence chain — revenue-grade measurement as immutable proof |
| T (Temporal) | 4 | Dispatch timing integrity — real-time market intervals, protection relay coordination |
| R (Relational) | 8 | Interconnection boundaries — point-of-coupling enforcement, balancing area limits |
| C5 | private | Generation and distribution operations — governed mode transitions, curtailment |
| C6 | private | Utility structure — NERC/NRC/IEC standards conformance, organizational hierarchy |
| SIL | Risk | MAGIC Tier | Bits | Governance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SIL 1 | Negligible | COMMUNITY | #35 | Basic metering and monitoring |
| SIL 2 | Marginal | BUSINESS | #43 | Grid protection, distribution automation |
| SIL 3 | Critical | ENTERPRISE | #63 | Transmission operations, market dispatch |
| SIL 4 | Catastrophic | AGENT | #127 | Nuclear reactor protection systems |
`` Standard: NRC 10 CFR 50 (Reactor Licensing), 10 CFR 73 (Physical Protection) SIL Range: SIL 3-4 Governance: AGENT (#127) minimum for reactor protection systems Application: Reactor control, safety systems, spent fuel management, radiation monitoring Key Hazards: Core damage, radiological release, criticality, loss of coolant Mitigation: Defense-in-depth, ECCS, containment, ALARA, NQA-1 quality assurance `
` Standard: NERC CIP (CIP-002 through CIP-014), NERC TPL-001-5 SIL Range: SIL 2-3 Governance: ENTERPRISE (#63) Application: BES operations, SCADA/EMS, protection relaying, transmission planning Key Hazards: Cascading failure, cyber intrusion, voltage collapse, frequency excursion Mitigation: N-1 contingency, redundant protection, CIP compliance, AGC `
` Standard: IEEE 1547, ANSI C84.1 (Voltage Ranges), IEEE C37 (Relaying) SIL Range: SIL 1-2 Governance: BUSINESS (#43) minimum Application: Feeder automation, voltage regulation, fault isolation, DER management Key Systems: ADMS, DERMS, FLISR, Volt-VAR optimization Innovation: MAGIC checkset governs DER interconnection, islanding transitions `
` Standard: IEC 61400 (Wind), IEC 61215/61730 (Solar), IEC 62817 (Trackers) SIL Range: SIL 1-2 Governance: BUSINESS (#43) minimum Application: Utility-scale generation, distributed generation, hybrid plants Key Hazards: Intermittency, grid instability, curtailment loss, inverter failure Innovation: MAGIC checkset governs curtailment decisions, ride-through compliance, ramp rates `
` Standard: API (American Petroleum Institute), IEC 61511 (Process Safety), OSHA PSM SIL Range: SIL 2-3 Governance: ENTERPRISE (#63) Application: Upstream (exploration/production), midstream (pipelines), downstream (refining) Key Hazards: Explosion, toxic release, pipeline rupture, well blowout Mitigation: SIS (Safety Instrumented Systems), BPCS, layer of protection analysis `
` Standard: FERC Orders (745, 828, 2222), ISO/RTO tariffs, OATT SIL Range: SIL 1-2 Governance: BUSINESS (#43) minimum Application: Day-ahead/real-time markets, capacity markets, ancillary services, DR Key Systems: Market clearing engines, settlement systems, metering infrastructure Innovation: MAGIC checkset governs market participation, settlement evidence, bid validation via COIN ``
| Standard | Scope | Governance |
|---|---|---|
| NERC CIP-002 to CIP-014 | BES cyber/physical security | ENTERPRISE (#63) |
| NRC 10 CFR 50 | Reactor licensing | AGENT (#127) |
| NRC 10 CFR 73 | Physical protection of nuclear | AGENT (#127) |
| IEC 61850 | Substation automation | ENTERPRISE (#63) |
| IEC 62351 | Power system information security | ENTERPRISE (#63) |
| IEEE 1547 (2018) | DER interconnection | BUSINESS (#43) |
| FERC Order 2222 | DER market participation | BUSINESS (#43) |
| IEC 61400 | Wind turbine design | BUSINESS (#43) |
| IEC 61215/61730 | PV module qualification/safety | BUSINESS (#43) |
| IEC 61511 | Process safety (oil & gas) | ENTERPRISE (#63) |
Gap: No existing system provides governance-gated energy dispatch with O(1) bitwise compliance checking across safety integrity levels from metering through market settlement.
| Competitor | Approach | MAGIC checkset Distinction |
|---|---|---|
| GE Grid Solutions | SCADA monitoring, grid analytics | Monitoring only, no governance-gated dispatch, no bitwise compliance |
| Schneider Electric | EcoStruxure grid management | Data acquisition and visualization, no governed actuation |
| Siemens Energy | Digital twin, Spectrum Power | Simulation and optimization, no bitwise governance verification |
| OSIsoft (AVEVA) PI | Historian, real-time data platform | Data aggregation, no governance framework, no SIL mapping |
| AutoGrid | DER management, demand response | Optimization algorithms, no formal governance language |
| PROV | Relevance | Claims |
|---|---|---|
| PROV-006 | PRIMARY | Governance-gated nuclear/grid robotic inspection, SIL mapping for reactor systems |
| PROV-002 | Secondary | COIN=WORK for energy market settlement, demand response attestation |
| PROV-003 | Supporting | Federated grid optimization across balancing areas, distributed generation coordination |
| PROV-001 | Foundational | MAGIC private-check encoding for energy governance verification |
| PROV-004 | Supporting | Transcompilation of NERC CIP/NRC standards to governed executables |
ENERGY × ROBOTICS = Nuclear/grid inspection robots (NRC + IEC 61508 + ISO 10218)
ENERGY × MANUFACTURING = Industrial energy management (ISO 50001 + NERC CIP)
ENERGY × LOGISTICS = Fuel supply chain, pipeline operations (API + ISO 28000)
ENERGY × SAFETY = Process safety, nuclear safety (IEC 61511 + NRC 10 CFR 50)
ENERGY × SECURITY = Grid cybersecurity, nuclear security (NERC CIP + 10 CFR 73)
ENERGY × DEFENSE = Military energy infrastructure (MIL-STD + NERC CIP)
ENERGY × FINANCE = Energy trading, carbon markets (FERC + commodity regulation)
ENERGY × AGRICULTURE = Rural electrification, agricultural energy (IEEE 1547 + USDA)
ENERGY × QUALITY = Grid reliability metrics (NERC TPL + ISO 9001)
ENERGY × GENOMICS = Bioenergy, biogas optimization (IEC 61400 + genomic sequencing)
10 cross-domain compositions. Each strengthens PROV-002 and PROV-003 patent claims.
The bulk electric system MUST maintain N-1 contingency at all times. No dispatch without verified stability margin.
Example: A 500MW generator trips offline. The system MUST have pre-verified that remaining generation and transmission capacity can absorb the loss without cascading failure. NERC TPL-001-5 requires this analysis before every dispatch interval.
Energy generation systems MUST enforce safety integrity levels proportional to consequence. Nuclear = AGENT minimum.
Example: A pressurized water reactor’s emergency core cooling system (ECCS) operates at SIL 4. The protection system MUST actuate within 0.5 seconds of a loss-of-coolant signal. No human override. Defense-in-depth: multiple independent barriers between fission products and the public.
Energy market participants MUST submit bids backed by verifiable generation capacity. Settlement MUST trace to metered delivery.
Example: A wind farm bids 200MW into the day-ahead market. The bid MUST be backed by weather-adjusted generation forecast. Settlement compares bid to actual delivery via revenue-grade metering (ANSI C12.20). Deviation penalties are automatic.
Energy operations MUST comply with emissions limits and environmental permits. Evidence MUST be continuous, not sampled.
Example: A coal plant holds a Title V permit capping SO₂ at 0.12 lb/MMBtu. CEMS (Continuous Emissions Monitoring) data is reported hourly to EPA. Exceedance triggers automatic notification. No manual override of the monitoring chain.
Nuclear facilities MUST maintain multiple independent barriers. No single failure can compromise public safety.
Example: Five barriers between fission products and the public: fuel pellet ceramic, fuel rod cladding, reactor coolant pressure boundary, containment building, site exclusion zone. Each barrier is independently governed. Loss of any one triggers escalation to the next level of emergency classification.
`` DECLARE(NuclearReactorLicensing) = NRC_10CFR50 × CANONIC
Where: NRC 10 CFR 50 provides Structure: - Safety analysis report (FSAR) - Technical specifications - Emergency operating procedures - Quality assurance program (NQA-1) - Environmental impact statement
CANONIC provides Governance: - C1: Reactor design basis claims - C2: Safety analysis evidence (FSAR Chapter 15) - Temporal: Operating license period, surveillance intervals - Relational: NRC/licensee/state jurisdictions - C5: Reactor operations (startup, shutdown, emergency) - C6: NRC/IEEE/ASME standards conformance
Result: NuclearReactorLicensing = AGENT (#127) minimum
Licensing Lifecycle: Design — Conceptual safety analysis Construct — FSAR submitted Test — Pre-operational testing License — NRC operating license issued Operate — Full power, governed at ENTERPRISE Protect = AGENT (#127) — Reactor protection systems active `
` DECLARE(GridReliabilityCompliance) = NERC_CIP × CANONIC
Where: NERC CIP provides Structure: - BES Cyber System categorization (CIP-002) - Electronic security perimeters (CIP-005) - System security management (CIP-007) - Incident reporting (CIP-008) - Recovery plans (CIP-009)
CANONIC provides Governance: - C1: BES asset classification claims - C2: Compliance evidence (audit artifacts) - Temporal: CIP assessment schedule, patch timelines - Relational: Reliability coordinator/BA/TOP boundaries - C5: Grid operations (dispatch, switching, load shed) - C6: NERC/IEEE/IEC standards conformance
Result: GridReliabilityCompliance = ENTERPRISE (#63)
Compliance Lifecycle: Identify — BES assets classified Protect — Security controls implemented Detect — Monitoring active Respond — Incident response executed Certify — NERC audit passed ``
| Validator | Checks | Example Failure |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | Grid stability and generation claims declared | Dispatch without stability analysis |
| C2 | Metering evidence chain complete, revenue-grade | Settlement without metered delivery |
| Temporal | Dispatch intervals, maintenance windows, relay coordination | Protection relay expired calibration |
| Relational | Interconnection boundaries, balancing area limits | Uncoordinated cross-BA transfer |
| C5 | Operations procedures executed, mode transitions governed | Reactor startup without NRC approval |
| C6 | NERC/NRC/IEC standards conformance validated | Non-compliant protection relay settings |
To create a CANONIC energy vertical:
Identify energy subdomain (Nuclear, Grid, Distribution, Renewable, Oil & Gas, Markets) Determine SIL level and map to MAGIC tier Create scope with CANON.md inheriting /ENERGY/ Define safety claims specific to generation type and grid function Map to regulatory framework (NERC CIP, NRC 10 CFR, IEC 61850) Implement validators for metering evidence, dispatch governance, safety compliance Document coverage with operational evidence
Result: Owned energy vertical with safety-governed, market-transparent operations.
| *ENERGY | SPECIFICATION | VERTICALS | INDUSTRIES* |